Thursday, May 27, 2010
Time Flies When You're Complaining About the New Jersey Plan... And Not Because It's Fun
June 15th, 1787, Night, 7:15: Today’s proceedings introduced a new plan: the New Jersey Plan. This plan does not bode well for us large states. It comes from the smaller states, introduced by a William Paterson of New Jersey. The man has an fondness for order, and he dreams of putting an end to the rebellions in the preceding years, such as Shay’s Rebellion. This plan stands for what the smaller states support: equal representation, and it was created to prevent us large states from overtaking them. This plan put before us, which I
sincerely hope will be rejected, consists of the following features:
1. The Congress that is presently under the Articles of Confederation be maintained, but shall be granted new powers, such as the power to “set taxes and force their collection” (reminds you of the Stamp Act, no?)
2. An executive elected by Congress: only the Plan allows it to consist of several persons.
3. This executive serves for one term but can be recalled “based on the requests of state governors.”
4. Fortunately, it calls for a judiciary that shall be elected by the executive and, like our Plan, it’s members will serve for life.
5. Laws set by Congress come before state laws.
There you have it. A plan that calls for only more debating. A smart reader would correctly infer that I do not favor this plan because it stands for equal representation! I believe in proportional representation! What we need is a compromise…
Well, would you look at the time! 7:25 already! Time flies when you're complaining about the New Jersey Plan!
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment